The History of Fad Diets and Why They Don’t Work

ADD TO MY ARTICLES

Fad diets have been around for centuries, captivating millions of people with promises of rapid weight loss and “miracle” health transformations. While these diets may seem appealing in the moment, they often fall short of their promises and can even cause harm. But why do we keep falling for them? Let’s take a look at the history of fad diets, how they’ve evolved, and why they simply don’t work in the long run.

The Early Days: The Birth of Fad Diets

Fad diets first gained widespread attention in the early 20th century. One of the first notorious diet trends was the “Hollywood Diet” of the 1920s, which claimed to help people lose weight by consuming a liquid mix of grape juice and water. Though it promised quick weight loss, it was nutritionally imbalanced and unsustainable.

Fast forward to the 1950s, and we saw the rise of the Cabbage Soup Diet, which instructed dieters to consume large quantities of low-calorie cabbage soup for a week. The belief was that this would speed up metabolism and lead to weight loss. While it might have caused initial water weight loss, it didn’t lead to lasting fat loss, and as soon as people went back to normal eating habits, the weight came back—often with a vengeance.

By the time the Atkins Diet became popular in the 1970s, people had already begun to realize that extreme restrictions often led to temporary results at best. This low-carb, high-fat approach promised to turn the body into a fat-burning machine. And while some people did lose weight on the Atkins Diet, many experienced energy slumps, nutrient deficiencies, and long-term difficulties maintaining the diet.

The Rise of Celebrity Diets: The '80s and '90s

In the 1980s and 1990s, diets linked to celebrities took off. The Grapefruit Diet was one such example, where dieters ate half a grapefruit before every meal, supposedly aiding in fat burning. Celebrities like Marilyn Monroe and other famous figures from the golden age of Hollywood were often associated with these extreme weight-loss regimens, which led many fans to follow suit.

Then came the South Beach Diet in the early 2000s - a low-carb, high-protein, and high-fat approach that was marketed as a more "sophisticated" version of Atkins. It gained traction, especially among those looking for a scientifically “validated” approach to weight loss. But as with other restrictive diets, many dieters found it difficult to maintain over time, and when the cycle of restriction and indulgence began, so did the inevitable weight regain.

The Evolution of Fads & Why They Don’t Work in the Long Run

Fast forward to today, and the landscape of fad diets has evolved to include a variety of diets… keto, low carb, high fat, carnivore, vegan… the list goes on. While some people may initially shed pounds, many diets are extreme, hard to maintain, and can lead to nutrient imbalances. 

There are several reasons why these diets don’t work in the long run:

1. Unsustainable Restrictions: Fad diets often require extreme restrictions that make them hard to maintain. When a diet is overly restrictive, it can lead to feelings of deprivation, making it easier to give up or binge once the diet ends.

2. Nutrient Imbalances: Many fad diets eliminate entire food groups or severely limit intake of essential nutrients. This can lead to deficiencies in vital vitamins and minerals, which can harm your overall health in the long term.

3. Metabolic Adaptation: When you drastically cut calories or eliminate whole food groups, your metabolism can slow down as your body tries to conserve energy. This means you might stop losing weight, even if you're still following the diet, and you could gain weight back as soon as you return to normal eating habits.

4. Psychological Toll: Constant dieting and the cycle of restriction and bingeing can have negative effects on mental health, leading to stress, anxiety, and even disordered eating habits. This emotional rollercoaster can make it harder to build a healthy relationship with food and your body.

5. The “Yo-Yo” Effect: Most people regain the weight they lost on a fad diet—and often more—once they return to their usual eating patterns. This cyclical nature of weight loss and gain, known as “yo-yo dieting,” is not only frustrating but can also be damaging to your metabolism and self-esteem.

What Works Instead?

The key to sustainable health and wellness is adopting a balanced, whole-food-based approach that you can maintain for the long term. Rather than focusing on restriction and elimination, the best approach is one that emphasizes nutrient-dense foods that nourish your body and keep you feeling energized.

Here are some foundational principles to consider:

1. Focus on Whole Foods: Emphasize fruits, vegetables, whole grains, lean proteins, and healthy fats. These foods provide the nutrients your body needs without depriving you of essential elements.

2. Moderation, Not Extremes: Instead of cutting out entire food groups, aim for balance. Enjoy a variety of foods in reasonable portions, without guilt or shame.

3. Sustainable Movement: Incorporate regular physical activity into your life, whether through walking, yoga, weightlifting, or dancing. Movement that you enjoy is key to making it a lasting part of your lifestyle.

5. Mindful Eating: Pay attention to your body’s hunger and fullness cues, and make meals an enjoyable, nourishing experience rather than a source of stress or shame.

6. Prioritize Mental Health: Address the emotional and psychological aspects of eating. A healthy relationship with food starts with a healthy relationship with yourself. HERE are some things you can do for self-love. 

While fad diets may promise quick fixes, they rarely deliver lasting results. The true path to health and well-being is not through extreme restrictions, but through balanced, mindful habits that nourish both body and mind. Instead of chasing after the next fad, focus on creating a sustainable, healthy lifestyle that you can maintain for years to come. Your body—and your mind—will thank you for it.

Take the stress out of cooking with 21-days of guided meal plans, shopping lists, and nutrition support. You’ll find all of this, and more, in our signature Clean Eating Program.